Read this first. Only someone who has looked at your car under proper lighting can say whether a given dent is a PDR repair. This page does not give success rates or prices, because we have not found a trustworthy public source for them. Quotes from Reddit are anecdotes, not rules. Not legal or insurance advice.
The short version
Across the sources below, the same four questions come up again and again:
- Is the paint broken? Cracked or chipped paint at the dent means the repair is no longer fully paintless.
- Is the metal stretched, sharply creased, or on an edge? Soft, round hail dents in open areas are the usual PDR candidates. Sharp dents, panel edges, and badly stretched panels are not.
- Can the technician reach the dent without drilling holes or removing structural parts? If not, PDR is usually the wrong tool.
- Is the part metal? PDR is a metal-panel method. Plastic bumper covers are repaired or replaced another way.
If the answer to all four is favorable, PDR is usually where a hail repair starts. Many hail repairs end up mixed: PDR on most panels, and conventional repair or replacement on the one or two that are past it.
1. Paint condition comes first
General Motors’ service bulletin on paintless dent repair lists “Dents with no broken paint on the surface” as an appropriate use, and “Dents that include cracked paint” as an inappropriate one. It tells technicians to inspect for cracks and says “a magnifying glass may be helpful; GM suggests using a 4x magnifying glass.”
Source: GM Service Bulletin 99-08-51-001F, “Paintless Dent Repair Process,” July 2023 (filed with NHTSA; applies to 2024 and prior GM cars and light trucks with steel outer panels).
The Dent Company, a hail-repair shop, says on its limitations page that chipped, cracked, or severely damaged paint “can’t be repaired using PDR alone.” Its example: if a hail dent breaks the paint and exposes the metal, the dent can still be pushed with PDR, “but repainting the affected area would be necessary.”
Source: The Dent Company, “FAQ – Limitations of Paintless Dent Repair (PDR)”. A shop’s own explainer, cited for its description of limits, not as an endorsement.
What to do: before you agree to a plan, ask the shop to show you any panel where they see broken paint, and whether that panel is being refinished, replaced, or repaired with PDR plus a spot repair.
2. Dent shape, size, and location
GM’s bulletin says PDR suits “Large or small dents, soft dents in body lines and contoured areas that allow reasonable access to the back side.” It lists as inappropriate: “Sharp dents in contoured areas, dents on the edge of panels, or dents in zero-clearance areas where glue stick dent removal has been unsuccessful.” It also notes that dents larger than its severity code 3 (over 3 inches up to 6 inches) “may still require conventional paint repairs.” That size note is written for GM’s transport-damage codes, not as a universal hail rule.
Source: GM Service Bulletin 99-08-51-001F.
The Dent Company adds that when a panel is “so dented, warped or just stretched,” replacement and repainting can be “the only option,” and that this is “more typical of a collision or heavy hail damage.”
Source: The Dent Company limitations FAQ.
3. Access: no drilled holes, no pulled-out structure
Hail often hits roofs, hoods, and roof rails, where the back of the panel is hard to reach. Technicians use two broad approaches: pushing from behind with rods, and pulling from the outside with glue tabs. GM describes glue pulling for areas with “minimal or zero access to the back side of the panel,” such as roof rails, pickup bed rails, and the roof skin near fixed glass.
What is not acceptable, according to I-CAR, the collision-repair training organization:
“When performing PDR, do not drill access holes. If holes must be cut to access the panel backside, PDR is not an acceptable option. Adding holes to a structural part can alter the structural integrity of the vehicle, creating collapse zones where none were intended.”
I-CAR Repairability Technical Support, “What does I-CAR say about drilling holes to perform PDR repairs?” The same answer says foam should not be removed and that “the finish may be damaged during dent removal.”
GM’s bulletin agrees: “The removal of structural components or drilling of holes in any panel is not recommended and may void the General Motors Corrosion Warranty.” Tesla’s Model Y body-repair manual says PDR is “an acceptable method for repairing cosmetic panel damage” as long as “holes are not drilled in any panel for tooling access.”
Sources: GM Service Bulletin 99-08-51-001F; Tesla Model Y Body Repair Manual, “Body Structure Materials and Allowed Operations”.
What to do: ask the technician how they will reach the roof and any rails — which trim or headliner comes down, or whether they will glue pull — and ask directly whether any holes will be drilled. Manufacturers publish their own repair procedures, and those can differ by make and model, so a good shop should be able to tell you what applies to your car.
4. Aluminum and plastic parts
Aluminum panels can often be repaired with PDR, but they take more care. The Dent Company says aluminum “stretches more easily and has a higher chance of cracking the paint if done by an inexperienced PDR technician,” that extra bracing can limit access, and that “Some PDR companies will not repair dents in aluminum because of this.” Note that the GM bulletin cited above is written for steel outer panels.
The same page says PDR “only works on metal body parts,” and that plastic bumpers and other non-metal parts have to be repaired or replaced by other methods.
Source: The Dent Company limitations FAQ.
What to do: if you know your hood, liftgate, or other panels are aluminum, ask the shop whether its technicians repair aluminum and how often.
Who “pushes” which repair?
Owners often assume the insurer wants the cheapest, roughest fix. Commenters who work in repair disagree with each other about this, which is a useful reminder that the dent decides more than the slogan does.
“Insurance pushes PDR as much as possible because it's cheaper (no need to paint). Shops tend to want conventional due to it costing more.”
u/Chemical-Medium-1324, 12 September 2026, America/Chicago, r/AutoBodyRepair, “2022 Tucson got hammered by hail — how hard can I push for PDR instead of filler & repaint?” Commenter opinion.
“Not every dent can be done with pdr. What you want and how physics and metal works are 2 different things.”
u/Gas-Squatch, same thread, 12 September 2026, America/Chicago. Commenter opinion.
“If the PDR isn’t fully able to get some of the dents out, then conventional repair will be needed to fully restore it to pre-loss condition anyways. Which would involve new paint. Make sure you don’t pick a shitty shop (and that the have a warranty on their work)”
u/HDauthentic, same thread, 12 September 2026, America/Chicago. Commenter advice, quoted as written.
A post in r/PaintlessDentRepair describes the opposite worry, after DFW storms: an owner sent to a preferred shop gets the car back “with a bunch of filler and a paint job that doesn't quite match the factory finish.” The poster’s advice: “Take the car to a specialist, get a second opinion, and look for a shop that shows you their work under a light board before you sign anything.”
Source: r/PaintlessDentRepair, “Why you should be careful with insurance 'preferred' body shops after a hail storm” (August 2026). One person’s account, not a finding about any shop or insurer.
And on the owner side, a June 2025 r/Autobody thread mostly told the poster not to try it themselves:
“Pdr is 100% legit and when done by a true pro it’s the perfect solution for hail damage. The cheapest pdr techs are not your best option…”
u/Gassquatches, 21 June 2025, America/Chicago, r/Autobody, “Paintless Dent Repair, Should I do it?” Commenter opinion. Another reply in the same thread: “Well don’t do it yourself! … If you make it worse it’s going to be more expensive and take more time to fix.”
Your choices in Texas
In Texas you can pick the shop, including a PDR-focused one. TDI’s auto insurance guide says: “Some companies might give you a list of preferred repair shops, but they can’t require you to use a shop on its list.” The same section sets the limits on what the insurer owes: it pays for repairs “only up to its actual cash value,” and it is “only required to pay for parts of like kind and quality.” TDI’s hail tip also says to “Get more than one bid or repair estimate.”
Sources: TDI, Auto insurance guide, Settling claims; TDI, “Hail damage to your home or car? What to do next.” For the Insurance Code sections behind the shop-choice rule, see our Texas hail claim checklist.
Choosing the shop does not mean you get to choose the method on a panel that, by the guidance above, is not a PDR repair. It does mean you can get a second opinion when a plan calls for filler and paint on panels where the paint looks unbroken.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Which panels are PDR, which are conventional repair, and which are replacement? Why, panel by panel?
- Can you show me the broken paint, sharp dents, or edge damage that rules out PDR on a panel?
- How will you reach the roof and rails? Will any holes be drilled? (I-CAR says no.)
- Are any of my panels aluminum, and do your technicians repair aluminum?
- Will you show me the finished panels under a light or reflection board?
- What written warranty comes with the work?
- If you find more damage once the work starts, how will you handle it with my insurer?
Want a rough sense of PDR cost first? The hail-repair cost estimator gives a cited, educational range. It is not a quote.
Sources opened for this guide
- GM Service Bulletin 99-08-51-001F, Paintless Dent Repair Process (July 2023, via NHTSA)
- I-CAR RTS, drilling holes for PDR
- Tesla Model Y Body Repair Manual, allowed operations
- The Dent Company, limitations of PDR
- TDI, Auto insurance guide
- TDI, hail damage tip
- r/AutoBodyRepair, Tucson hail / PDR thread (September 2026)
- r/PaintlessDentRepair, preferred-shop thread (August 2026)
- r/Autobody, “Paintless Dent Repair, Should I do it?” (June 2025)