Read this first. This is not legal advice, and we are not lawyers. We quote the statutes and official pages we opened and say plainly where they stop. Your own policy wording matters, and a lawyer or your insurer can answer for your facts. Reddit posts and ads quoted below are examples of what owners are told, not evidence that any shop broke a law.
The short version
- The 2019 Texas deductible-waiver law is written for real-property insurance. Its offense and its required contract notice apply to a “property insurance policy,” which the Insurance Code defines as first-party coverage “for loss of or damage to real property.” That is the law behind TDI’s roofing and home-contractor warnings. Neither statute mentions cars.
- That does not make every auto offer fine. The Penal Code’s insurance-fraud section is not limited to home policies. A padded estimate, a bill for work that was not done, or a payment arranged “with intent to defraud or deceive an insurer” can be insurance fraud on an auto claim too.
- For your car, TDI’s plain rule is that you owe the deductible. “The insurance company will subtract your deductible from your payment if you used your own insurance. You will owe that deductible to the contractor or body shop.”
- The money has to come from somewhere. TDI names the usual sources on its home-contractor page: a higher estimate than the real repair cost, a rebate or credit, or cut corners. Ask which one a shop means, in writing.
What owners are hearing
The offer shows up in ads and at the counter. A San Antonio PDR company’s post on X in April 2025 advertised “Insurance-approved, ZERO deductible.” We do not know what arrangement was behind that line, and we are not suggesting the company did anything unlawful; it is here as an example of the wording owners see.
Source: X post, 14 April 2025 (09:00 America/Chicago). Cited only as an example of advertising language, not as an endorsement or an accusation.
Owners then try to work out whether to take it. In Austin, after a 2023 storm, one owner asked the opposite question most people ask:
“Unfortunately I have a $2k deductible - any reputable PDR groups who also offer deductible assistance?”
r/Austin, “Paintless Dent Removal - Deductible Assistance Recommendations” (September 2023). Original post; an owner’s question.
A Denver owner whose shop offered to cover the deductible “up to 1000” worried about the same thing many Texans ask:
“I’m a little concerned because I’m worried that’s insurance fraud and I don’t want to be tied up in that. Someone on one of these posts mentioned a few shops around here do that by upcharging the insurance the amount of your deductible.”
r/Denver, “Hail repair shops and covering your deductible” (July 2024). Original post. Colorado, not Texas; Texas statutes below do not apply in Colorado.
Not every shop makes the offer. A Frisco hail-repair company answers “Do you offer incentives or pay deductibles?” on its FAQ with: “No. Texas Dent Company does not offer deductible reimbursement or financial incentives to customers.” It also says: “Your deductible is set by your insurance policy and remains the policyholder’s responsibility.”
Source: Texas Dent Company, FAQs, “Costs, Deductibles & Payments.” Cited as an example of a shop’s published policy, not as a recommendation or a directory listing.
For the East Texas owner thread where commenters split over whether a “2019 law” bans these offers, see section 4 of our Texas hail claim checklist.
1. What the 2019 law actually says
The law people usually mean is House Bill 2102 (2019). It added Insurance Code Chapter 707 and rewrote Business & Commerce Code §27.02, effective 1 September 2019.
- Who must pay. Insurance Code §707.002: “A person insured under a property insurance policy shall pay any deductible applicable to a first-party claim made under the policy.”
- Which policies. §707.001(2) defines a “property insurance policy” as one “that provides first-party coverage for loss of or damage to real property.” Business & Commerce Code §27.02(a) borrows that same definition.
- What a seller may not do. Under §27.02(c), a seller commits an offense if, without the insurer’s consent, it advertises, promises, or actually does any of these when the work will be paid from a property-insurance claim: “pay, waive, absorb, or otherwise decline to charge or collect the amount of the insured’s deductible”; give “a rebate or credit” that offsets the deductible; or “in any other manner assist the insured in avoiding monetary payment of the required insurance deductible.”
- Penalty. §27.02(d): a Class B misdemeanor.
- Contract notice. §27.02(b): a contract of $1,000 or more “reasonably expected to be paid wholly or partly from the proceeds of a claim under a property insurance policy” must carry a bold notice that “Texas law requires a person insured under a property insurance policy to pay any deductible.”
- Proof of payment. §707.004 lets an insurer with replacement-cost coverage hold back withheld depreciation until it gets “reasonable proof of payment” of the deductible, such as “a canceled check, money order receipt, credit card statement,” or a financing contract.
Sources: Texas Insurance Code Chapter 707; Business & Commerce Code Chapter 27, §27.02; HB 2102, 86th Legislature, enrolled text.
The House committee’s bill analysis explains the target: “It has been reported that fraudulent actors in the roofing industry are falsely claiming they can waive or absorb an insurance deductible, which results in consumers receiving lesser work or facing higher insurance premiums down the road.”
Source: Bill analysis, C.S.H.B. 2102, House Insurance Committee report, Background and Purpose.
2. Why “it’s illegal since 2019” is not the whole story for cars
Three things in the official text matter for a hail-damaged car.
The definition is about real property. The statute’s definition stops at “real property.” Auto comprehensive coverage, the part of a car policy that TDI says pays when a car is damaged “by fire, flood, vandalism or something other than a collision,” is not described anywhere in Chapter 707 or §27.02.
The old version was broader. Before 2019, §27.02 applied when a good or service was “paid for by the consumer from proceeds of a property or casualty insurance policy,” but only when the seller charged more than its “usual and customary charge” by at least the deductible it paid or rebated. The old law also made it an offense for the insured to submit such a claim unless the insured “promptly notifies the insurer of the excessive charges.” HB 2102 struck that text and replaced it with the real-property version above.
Source: HB 2102 enrolled text, Section 2 (deleted language appears in brackets). Coverage description from the TDI auto insurance guide (last updated 11 December 2025).
TDI’s own waiver pages are written for homes. TDI’s “Is it OK for a contractor to waive my deductible?” opens: “No. A deductible is part of your home insurance policy.” Its “Roofing and insurance: Know the law” page says it is illegal “for a contractor to offer to waive, rebate, or absorb a property policyholder’s deductible,” and lists Chapter 707 and §27.02 as the laws.
Sources: TDI, “Is it OK for a contractor to waive my deductible?” (last updated 9 December 2025); TDI, “Roofing and insurance: Know the law” (last updated 24 March 2025).
So the precise statement is this: the statute that makes a deductible waiver itself a crime is written for real-property policies, and we found no official Texas source extending it to auto claims. That is narrower than “auto deductible offers are legal.” We are not saying that, for the reasons in the next section.
3. What still applies to an auto hail claim
Insurance fraud is not limited to home policies. Penal Code Chapter 35 defines “insurance policy” broadly, including any “contract of insurance” and “any instrument authorized to be regulated by the Texas Department of Insurance.” Under §35.02(a), a person commits insurance fraud if, “with intent to defraud or deceive an insurer,” the person prepares or presents, in support of a claim, a statement the person “knows contains false or misleading material information.” Under §35.02(b), it is also an offense when a person, with the same intent, “solicits, offers, pays, or receives a benefit in connection with the furnishing of goods or services for which a claim for payment is submitted under an insurance policy.”
The grade depends on the value of the claim. For example, a claim of $750 to under $2,500 is a Class A misdemeanor, and $2,500 to under $30,000 is a state jail felony. If someone submits a bill for goods or services to the insurer, the law presumes, subject to rebuttal, that the person “caused the claim for payment to be prepared or presented.”
Source: Texas Penal Code Chapter 35, §§35.01, 35.02(a), (b), (c), (h).
Note that §35.02(b) speaks of anyone who “receives a benefit,” not only the seller. Intent to defraud or deceive the insurer is the key element. Whether a particular arrangement meets it is a question for prosecutors and courts, not for this page.
Your policy still has a deductible. TDI’s auto guide: “You must pay a deductible for collision, comprehensive, and uninsured/underinsured motorist claims. A deductible is the amount of a claim that you must pay yourself.” Its claim tip, which covers car claims, says you “will owe that deductible to the contractor or body shop.”
Sources: TDI auto insurance guide, “Deductibles and dollar limits”; TDI, Steps to getting your home or car insurance claim paid, Step 4 (last updated 16 April 2025).
4. Where the money comes from
A shop that does not collect your deductible is short that amount. TDI’s home-contractor page describes the common ways that gap gets filled. The legal labels on that page are about homes; the arithmetic is the same on a car.
- A higher estimate. “One way is by giving you an estimate that’s higher than the actual cost to repair … The contractor then uses the extra money paid by the insurance company to cover your deductible.” TDI says that may mean “sending false information to your insurance company about the cost of repairs. That would be fraud.”
- A rebate or credit. “Some contractors might offer rebates or credits in the amount of your deductible.”
- Less work. A contractor who waives the deductible “is likely making up the difference by cutting corners or using lower quality products.”
Source: TDI, “Is it OK for a contractor to waive my deductible?”, “How would a contractor help me avoid paying a deductible?” and “What’s the harm?”
On a hail car, “less work” can look like dents that are left in place, panels that are listed on the estimate but not fully repaired, or a lower-quality finish. Because a hail estimate can include dozens of small dents per panel, it is hard for an owner to check afterward. That is why the questions below ask for specifics.
5. Questions to ask before you sign
- “How exactly are you covering my deductible?” Get the answer in writing: a lower price, a rebate, a gift card, or a referral payment are not the same thing.
- “Will the amount you bill my insurer be the same as the work you do?” Ask for the estimate they will send to the insurer and compare it with the insurer’s estimate. TDI says to show shops the insurer’s estimate and to talk to the insurer about differences.
- “Is anything on the estimate not going to be repaired?” If yes, ask why it is still on the estimate.
- “Does my insurer know and agree?” For home policies the statute turns on “the insurer’s consent.” For a car there is no such statutory exception to point to, but asking your insurer first is still the cautious step, and it is what TDI tells homeowners to do.
- Don’t sign blanks, and don’t pay in full up front. Both are on TDI’s claim tip.
- Get more than one estimate. TDI: “Get estimates from more than one contractor or body shop.”
- Pay your deductible in a traceable way. A check or card leaves the kind of record §707.004 describes for home claims; it is also what you will want if the work is disputed later.
Sources: TDI claim-paid tip, Step 3; TDI deductible-waiver tip, “What should I do if a contractor offers to waive my deductible?”; Insurance Code §707.004.
6. Who to call
- Your insurance company, first, about the offer and your deductible. TDI: “Talk to your insurance company first.”
- A body shop problem (work quality, billing, a business practice): TDI says it “doesn’t regulate service providers, like body shops,” and sends body-shop questions and complaints to the Texas Attorney General, 800-621-0508.
- A suspected padded or false claim: TDI’s fraud page says to file a fraud report “if you suspect a criminal act, such as filing a false or padded insurance claim.” Questions about reporting go to FraudUnit@tdi.texas.gov. If you are not sure whether something is a complaint or a fraud report, TDI’s Help Line is 800-252-3439 (Monday to Friday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Central time).
- A dispute with your insurer about the amount: that is a complaint, not a fraud report. See “Resolving problems” in the TDI auto guide.
Sources: TDI deductible-waiver tip; TDI, “Not sure who to call?”; TDI, Report fraud (last updated 18 October 2024); TDI auto insurance guide.
What this page does not do
- It does not say any named shop broke a law. The ad and posts are examples of what owners are told.
- It does not say auto deductible offers are legal, and it does not say they are always crimes. It quotes the statutes and says where each one applies.
- It does not cover other states. Colorado and other hail states have their own rules, and we have not opened them for this page.
Related: After hail hits your car in Texas (the full claim checklist) and PDR or body shop after hail?
Sources opened for this guide
- Texas Insurance Code Chapter 707, Payment of Insurance Deductible
- Texas Business & Commerce Code Chapter 27 (§27.02)
- HB 2102, 86th Legislature (2019), enrolled bill text
- C.S.H.B. 2102 bill analysis, House Insurance Committee
- Texas Penal Code Chapter 35, Insurance Fraud
- TDI, “Is it OK for a contractor to waive my deductible?”
- TDI, “Roofing and insurance: Know the law”
- TDI, “Steps to getting your home or car insurance claim paid”
- TDI, Auto insurance guide
- TDI, “Not sure who to call with your question or complaint?”
- TDI, Report fraud
- Texas Dent Company, FAQs (a shop’s published deductible policy)
- X post advertising “ZERO deductible” PDR in San Antonio (14 April 2025)
- r/Austin, “Paintless Dent Removal - Deductible Assistance Recommendations” (September 2023)
- r/Denver, “Hail repair shops and covering your deductible” (July 2024)